26 Comments
User's avatar
Brent Allen Myers's avatar

Well done Geoff. As always, your links lead to wonderful rabbit holes.

One quibble = a course rating for normal people should ask if normal people can afford to play there. When the greens fee is > than the Old Course and > my annual dues at home (Fortrose & Rosemarkie) the answer is in the neighborhood 4/10.

Expand full comment
Geoff Shackelford's avatar

Yes I'm pretty conflicted over that. In the book I conceded that the "experience" is going to always impact people no matter how hard we try to focus on design. And like seeing a movie in a certain kind of theater or sports event at a well run facility, the surrounding stuff does impact our enjoyment. So certainly price and the attitude of the people at the place can impact your enjoyment (if I had a dollar for the number of times I've heard, "great course, lousy experience" for a few places in LA I'd be able to afford a membership to every club in town!

Expand full comment
Mike Loustalot's avatar

I've played your course sir! It was awesome on the spit of land next to the caravan park.

Expand full comment
Dan Davies's avatar

Comprehensive doesn’t come close. Chapeau Geoff

Expand full comment
Geoff Shackelford's avatar

Thanks Dan, always fun to research the best places!

Expand full comment
Mike Kiley's avatar

Played it several years ago. Don't recall any holes save 1 & 18, just recall the great weather, terrain and overall great vibe. Played Portmarnock the day prior and remember more of those holes.

Expand full comment
g g's avatar
4dEdited

What? Portmarnock is a classic as well but entirely different

Expand full comment
Geoff Shackelford's avatar

Interesting, usually it's the opposite just given the difference in properties as gg notes. They're so different. But glad the weather and vibe were great, that's all ultimately matters.

Expand full comment
PDB's avatar

Thank you for this comprehensive preview, Geoff. My dad and I are flying from the States to Ireland for our first Open and am beyond excited. Your preview raised the level of anticipation by quite a bit.

Expand full comment
Geoff Shackelford's avatar

Outstanding! Let me know what days you're out and we'll try to say hi.

Expand full comment
PDB's avatar

Awesome. We have tickets for Friday and Saturday.

Expand full comment
Pmbenedict@icloud.com's avatar

The Quad introduced me to Holderness & Bourne. Bought a bunch of stuff. Has Bourne ever introduced you to his cousin Jason?

Expand full comment
g g's avatar
4dEdited

nice article GS

spot on vid by Andy and TFE, very on brand!!

fortunate to have played there in 2019...great course etc... great town....historical

Expand full comment
Mike Walsh's avatar

Enjoyed this as always. I hope to run into you next week - I need some advice and suspect you’d have plenty of good stuff to offer

Expand full comment
Geoff Shackelford's avatar

I'll be on the lookout for you Mike!

Expand full comment
Patrick Kelley's avatar

Bravo 👏

Expand full comment
KLG25's avatar

Spectacular! And now a moment for our sponsor while I order something from them in support of the Quad.

Expand full comment
Joseph C Garbrous's avatar

"3.75 mm: Height greens were cut in 2019" ... typo? Decimal point?

Expand full comment
Geoff Shackelford's avatar

Sorry, misplaced decimal point! This mm thing is scrambling my limited mental math skills.

Expand full comment
Joseph C Garbrous's avatar

It's a trade-off... I have math skills but no golf skills.

Expand full comment
Joseph C Garbrous's avatar

"Links Collection Capital" ... sounds like burn, rape, pillage private equity making their move.

See Brent Myers comment.

Expand full comment
Geoff Shackelford's avatar

It's not the quaintest sounding name is it?

Expand full comment
John A's avatar

Geoff, I'm just a little more excited about the Open this year than usual because I will have the opportunity to play there in September along with our buddy, the UK Golf Guy. It's always so enjoyable to view the high-quality videos of the course, then read your informative and interesting comments and analysis of both the course and the tournament, then watch the tournament on TV, and then play the course a few weeks later. Just an all-around great experience.

Expand full comment
Michael E.'s avatar

After your excellent summary I want to do two things 1) play Royal Portrush 2) purchase two of those H&B sweaters - Heathered Skye for me and Heathered Abaco for she-who-must-be-obeyed. (Credit: D. Feherty)

Expand full comment
Joseph C Garbrous's avatar

I think she who must be obeyed pre dated Feherty ... I think it was Adam & Eve ... didn't turn out well for them.

Expand full comment
A Fitzgerald O’Connor's avatar

Great article with or without the typos

Hope to meet up with you at Portrush We’re playing R Port Stewart Monday am. Tuesday Practice Day at OC Wednesday playing Castlerock am Thursday Friday OC Talking of clubs our four can rustle up Rye, New Zealand, R Worlington St George’s Hill, R Blackheath and R&A all because someone else thought we were OK blokes!

Best

A

Ps Fortrose and Rosemarkie great golf course and much fun!!

Expand full comment